Can You Really Install New Shingles Over Existing Asphalt Shingles?

If you’re considering a roof replacement for your home in Hampstead, MD, you may have come across the term “nail-over reroof.” This method involves installing new shingles directly over your existing asphalt shingles. While it can save money upfront, there are important factors to weigh before deciding if it’s the right option for your home. Let’s dive into the specifics of installing new shingles over an existing roof and explore the pros, cons, and conditions required for a successful nail-over reroof.

Answering The Question: Can You Really Install New Shingles Over Existing Asphalt Shingles?

What Is a Nail-Over Reroof?

A nail-over reroof allows homeowners to place a new layer of asphalt shingles over their current roof without a complete tear-off. This method is most commonly used when the existing shingles are nearing the end of their lifespan but are still relatively flat and in decent condition. However, not every roof qualifies for a nail-over. Factors like the number of existing layers, the state of your roof deck, and the presence of flashing or penetrations play a big role in determining if this method is feasible.

Advantages of Installing New Shingles Over Existing Asphalt Shingles

1. Cost Savings

The primary advantage of a nail-over reroof is the cost savings. By skipping the tear-off process, homeowners avoid dump fees, underlayment replacement, and additional labor costs. This can make a significant difference for those working within a strict budget. However, it’s important to remember that while the upfront costs are lower, potential long-term issues could offset these savings.

2. Faster Installation

Because the tear-off process is eliminated, nail-over reroofing is faster than a complete roof replacement. This can be particularly appealing during Maryland’s unpredictable weather seasons, where time is of the essence.

3. Eco-Friendly Option

By not removing the old shingles, less waste ends up in landfills, making this method a more environmentally friendly choice. For homeowners looking to minimize their ecological footprint, this can be a compelling benefit.

Potential Drawbacks of Nail-Over Reroofing

1. Limited to One Additional Layer

Most building codes, including those in Maryland, limit roofs to two layers of shingles for safety and structural reasons. If your roof already has two layers, a complete tear-off is mandatory.

2. Aesthetic Concerns

If you’re upgrading from 3-tab shingles to architectural shingles, the size difference can create an uneven, lumpy appearance. This happens because 3-tab shingles have a smaller exposure than architectural ones, causing noticeable humps where the layers overlap.

3. Reused Flashing

Roof flashing, which prevents water from seeping into your home around vents, chimneys, and walls, cannot be replaced during a nail-over reroof. This leaves you reliant on the integrity of the existing flashing, which could compromise the roof’s water-tightness.

4. Harder to Detect and Repair Leaks

When leaks occur in a double-layered roof, finding their origin can be challenging. Water might travel through both layers before entering your home, making it more difficult to pinpoint the exact source of the issue. This can result in higher repair costs down the road.

5. Inability to Inspect the Decking

A critical step in a full roof replacement is inspecting the roof decking for damage or rot. Without removing the old shingles, any issues with the decking remain hidden. This could lead to more severe structural problems in the future.

Conditions for a Nail-Over Reroof

Not every roof is a candidate for a nail-over reroof. Here are the conditions that must be met for this method to work:

• Flat and Secure Shingles: Your current shingles must be flat and free of significant curling, blistering, or damage.
• Minimal Penetrations and Flashing: Roofs with minimal vents, chimneys, or other penetrations are better suited for nail-over installations.
• Good Roof Decking: The underlying decking must be in good condition without any signs of rot or structural compromise.
• One Existing Layer: Building codes allow for only one additional layer of shingles. If your roof already has two layers, a complete tear-off is necessary.

The Cost of a Nail-Over Reroof Versus a Full Roof Replacement

While a nail-over reroof is less expensive upfront, it’s essential to consider the long-term implications. A full roof replacement, though costlier, ensures that all components of your roofing system are in optimal condition. This includes new underlayment, flashing, and a thorough inspection of the decking. The cost of a new asphalt shingle roof can range from $4.00 to $8.00 per square foot, depending on the quality of the shingles. A nail-over reroof will typically be on the lower end of that spectrum, as it eliminates many of the materials and labor costs associated with a full replacement. However, skimping on these components now could result in costly repairs or even a premature roof replacement later.

Is a Nail-Over Reroof Right for You?

Deciding whether to install new shingles over your existing roof depends on your budget, the condition of your current roof, and your long-term goals for your home. While the cost savings and faster installation of a nail-over reroof are appealing, the potential drawbacks, such as reduced durability and difficulty detecting leaks, must be carefully considered. For Maryland homeowners, the region’s seasonal weather changes—ranging from heavy summer storms to freezing winter temperatures—can take a toll on roofing systems. Opting for a full roof replacement provides the peace of mind that your home is well-protected, no matter the weather.

Contact Roof Right For Roof Shingle Replacements in Maryland

At Roof Right, we understand that every homeowner’s situation is unique. Whether you’re considering a nail-over reroof or a full roof replacement, our experienced team is here to guide you through the process. We’ll assess your roof’s condition, provide honest recommendations, and ensure the highest quality workmanship for your home. Don’t leave your roofing decisions to chance—trust Roof Right to deliver reliable, long-lasting solutions. Contact us today to schedule an inspection and get started on your roof replacement journey. Call now or visit our website to learn more about our services tailored to Maryland homeowners!

Areas We Serve

If you're looking for a roof contractor in Maryland, give Roof Right a call today at (410)-374-5923 to schedule an appointment!